Christopher Nolan’s epic film The Odyssey has yet to premiere but has already become one of the most hotly debated movies of the year. The latest trailer has met with a massive negative reaction on YouTube and is described by multiple outlets as one of the most disliked Hollywood trailers ever.

The criticism has mainly focused on the film’s casting choices and the creative decisions Nolan has made in his interpretation of Homer’s classic epic. Especially contentious is the casting of Kenyan-Mexican actress Lupita Nyong’o as Helen of Troy, a character traditionally described as a Greek woman.

Critics argue that Hollywood increasingly chooses to reinterpret historical and mythological figures through modern identity-political ideals rather than sticking to historical or literary sources.

Elliot Page is another big name that has sparked debate. Page first gained international fame in the film Juno, in which she played the leading role as a pregnant teenager. In 2020, Page came out publicly as transgender, changing her name from Ellen Page to Elliot Page. Since then, Page has continued to work as an actor and has become one of the most well-known transgender people in Hollywood.

READ ALSO: New Politically Correct Version of Saltkråkan Panned

In The Odyssey, Page plays the role of Sinon, a Greek soldier connected to the story of the Trojan Horse. Critics responding to this casting have mainly pointed to the fact that a trans actor is portraying a male warrior from ancient times. Supporters of the casting, however, argue that an actor’s gender identity doesn’t need to determine whether they can portray a fictional character.

Zendaya as the goddess Athena has also provoked discussion. In Greek mythology, Athena is a central Olympian goddess, often associated with wisdom, strategy, and warfare. Critics have questioned why Nolan didn’t choose an actor with Greek or Southern European heritage, while others have pointed out that the gods in mythology aren’t historical persons but symbolic figures.

Another debated choice is rapper Travis Scott, who’s been given a role in the film as a bard. The criticism here has mainly centered on the decision to cast a modern hip-hop artist with little acting experience in one of the year’s biggest historical fantasy films.

Modern Expressions

The reactions, however, haven’t solely concerned the casting. Many viewers have also objected to the American accents, modern expressions, and dialogue, which critics say break the illusion of the ancient world. On social media, several users have described the film as a historical tale filtered through a contemporary Hollywood lens.

The debate surrounding The Odyssey is far from unique. Over the past few years, several major productions have become embroiled in similar controversies. Disney’s The Little Mermaid sparked intense discussion after the casting of Halle Bailey as Ariel, while Snow White was criticized for significant changes to the classic fairy tale and statements from lead actress Rachel Zegler.

TV series such as The Rings of Power and The Wheel of Time have also faced criticism from parts of the audience who feel that modern political messages have taken precedence over fidelity to the source material.

Political Correctness is Destroying Culture

Critics argue that the film and television industry repeatedly underestimates audiences’ desire for authentic adaptations of well-known stories. They point out that numerous productions with similar controversies have also struggled to meet financial expectations and believe that Hollywood hasn’t learned from previous backlash.

Others, however, defend the development, emphasizing that classic stories have always been interpreted in new ways and that filmmakers must have the artistic freedom to make their own versions.

Christopher Nolan himself has downplayed the criticism, saying that early reactions “come with the territory” and that audiences should judge the movie after it premieres. Whether the widespread online criticism will affect ticket sales remains to be seen when The Odyssey reaches theaters.

Trailer:

READ ALSO: Amazon Making Series with Black, Disabled and Gay English King